Fluffernutter Cookie Tin

Fluffernutter Cookie Tin

Sweet, salty, and seriously addictive.

This tin features 5 thick, bakery-style peanut butter cookies, made with a rich, soft dough and loaded with Nutter Butter cookie pieces baked throughout. Each cookie is stuffed with a smooth, creamy peanut butter center, creating a warm, melt-in-the-middle bite with every break.

Finished with marshmallow fluff on top, these cookies deliver the perfect balance of salty peanut butter, sweet marshmallow, and soft, gooey texture — a nostalgic combination taken to the next level.

Break one open for a warm, peanut butter-filled center with soft marshmallow sweetness in every bite.

What’s inside:

• 5 stuffed peanut butter cookies

• Creamy peanut butter-filled center in every cookie

• Nutter Butter cookie pieces baked into the dough

• Marshmallow fluff topping

• Thick, soft-baked texture with a gooey interior

Rich, comforting, and nostalgic — this is the ultimate peanut butter and marshmallow experience, the Star & Sugar way.

📦 Tin Details

• Wooden tin

• 6-inch diameter

• Approximately 1 lb total